Drax climate hoax

425

“Our ambition is to become carbon negative by 2030”

At the November 2019 “Capital Markets Day,” Drax stated their ambition, explaining “being carbon negative means that we will be removing more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere than we produce throughout our operations – creating a negative carbon footprint for the company.”

This is an incompatible dream with what Drax is and what it does. Drax does not appreciate the climate emergency and is not providing resilient energy generation.

The Drax Group is a massive fossil fuel-fired power generation company and wood pellet company. Changing from burning coal, to burning forests, to burning natural gas is moving Drax and the UK in a negative direction. How is building a new 3.6 GW natural gas-fired plant helping the climate? Putting all your eggs in one basket near family neighborhoods is a bad strategy.

Ignoring the climate emergency

Drax is burning U.S. forests pretending to care for the planet and providing poor quality jobs for low-income communities in Arkansas, Louisiana and Mississippi. Pollution, road congestion, and noise will hardly benefit these communities.

Is the Arkansas Economic Development Commission and the Arkansas Teachers Retirement System funding the Drax mills like the Highland Pellet Mill?

Last month, “Burning the forests” explained the plans to build three pellet mills, the so-called Arkansas Bioenergy mills. At the time, I was unaware of their business strategy and sustainability plans.

In 2019, 65 percent of the pellets burned by the UK Drax station came from the Southeastern United States, around 4.6 million tons.

Drax created the wood pellet industry. Enviva, Highland Pellets, and others have long term contracts with Drax. Japan and other nations like what they see. If it’s good enough for the United Kingdom, it is good for them. They can recognize a loophole or two.

Failed Solutions

Even after the White Rose debacle, Drax still pretends Carbon Capture and Storage will eliminate carbon dioxide emissions. Drax knows about the Mississippi Kemper CCS, with billions of dollars and years wasted while the Kemper team used smoke and mirrors to show progress. Kemper is now the world’s most expensive natural gas plant. Is Drax following the Kemper path?

Drax ignores new technology

Drax is not investing in offshore wind, solar energy generation, nor grid energy storage solutions. The UK has a new supercooled air long-term energy storage facility for the grid.

Drax’s central generation will not help the grid to deal with power blackouts. Drax is joined at the hip with the UK National Grid. Drax needs the Grid, but does the Grid need Drax?

Natural gas is worse than coal for the climate

Natural gas (is 90 percent methane gas. NG is a greenhouse gas and creates carbon dioxide during combustion.

Coal is transported in open cars and stored at the power plant without special enclosures and zero emissions. Methane is a colorless odorless gas that leaks from the shale well to the flame. NG emissions are ignored to reduce the cost. If you can’t see a gas leak, you can pretend it’s not there.

The climate warming potential of methane is 84 times more than the warming of carbon dioxide for the first 20-years.

Moomaw says no more loopholes, let’s solve the problem

Last December the United Nations Climate Change Conference went into overtime trying to reach an agreement on higher reductions on carbon emissions. Some countries did not show up, as if building walls will keep Americans safe.

William Moomaw, a renowned climate scientist, gave a dire warning for politicians and humanity on YouTube. He spoke with great concern and despair about the speed of the climate emergency and the slow progress made reducing carbon emissions. He said the goal is zero emissions, not net-zero! He explains why carbon neutrality is not the solution – “climate neutrality means that I can continue emitting and someone else, someplace else, at some other time, will somehow have planted enough trees to remove that amount of carbon dioxide.”

Please visit the Wendell State Forest Alliance, save our climate and our forests, wendellforest.org

Dr. Luis Contreras

8 COMMENTS

  1. Enviva, Drax Biomass, and Highland Pellets will get a link for this op-ed.

    Hope they take the time to comment. This is not the whole enchilada, just my opinion

    I will reply quickly to all comments – thank you

  2. Breakthrough on energy storage

    June 2020 – Construction is beginning on the world’s largest liquid air battery to store solar and wind electricity and reduce carbon emissions from fossil-fuel power plants.

    Air is everywhere, Liquid Air batteries can be constructed anywhere running on green power.

    The UK project near Manchester, will use spare solar and wind energy to compress air into a liquid and store it. When energy demand is higher, the liquid air is released back into a gas, powering a turbine that puts the green energy back into the grid.

    Storage has been the missing piece for green energy. Coal-fired baseload power plants for bulk power generation were designed to run all the time, but they never do. This is like driving a 1920’s gasoline car to provide taxi service around the clock, until the tires fall out. When power plants fail standby units are needed until spare parts are found – or made from old blueprints.

    The new project will be the largest in the world outside of pumped hydro schemes, which require a mountain reservoir to store water.

    The new liquid air battery is due to be operational in 2022 and will power up to 200,000 homes for five hours, and store power for many weeks.

    The UK government has supported the project with a US$12.5 million grant, bringing greater flexibility to Britain’s electricity grid, and creating green-collar jobs in Greater Manchester.

    https://www.southernenvironment.org/cases-and-projects/biomass-energy-in-the-south

  3. We were warned …

    The world’s people face “untold suffering due to the climate crisis” unless there are major transformations to global society, according to a stark warning from more than 11,000 scientists.

    Nov 2019 – Climate emergency: 11,000 scientists warn of untold suffering.

    “The climate crisis has arrived and is accelerating faster than most scientists expected. It is more severe than anticipated, threatening natural ecosystems and the fate of humanity.”

    “We declare clearly and unequivocally that planet Earth is facing a climate emergency, to secure a sustainable future, we must change how we live. This entails major transformations in the ways our global society functions and interacts with natural ecosystems.”

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/nov/05/climate-crisis-11000-scientists-warn-of-untold-suffering

  4. Six months left … that is all

    June 18, 2020 – “The world has only six months to change the course of the climate emergency and prevent a post-lockdown rebound in greenhouse gas emissions that would overwhelm efforts to stave off climate catastrophe,” said Fatih Birol, Executive Director of the International Energy Agency.

    Governments are planning to spend US$9 trillion globally in the next few months trying to rescue their economies from the coronavirus crisis.

    The stimulus packages will determine the shape of the global economy for the next three years, and within that time emissions must fall sharply and permanently, or the climate targets will be out of reach.

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jun/18/world-has-six-months-to-avert-climate-crisis-says-energy-expert

Leave a Comment