Empathetic Surfing
I’ve been reading a book that a good friend lent me—a collection of columns written by a conservative commentator I’d never before heard of, but whom my friend has long held in high regard. For decades, this writer regularly contributed to high profile news sources, yet he never registered on my radar. Probably because I thought he wasn’t talking to me—or at least that I wouldn’t want to hear what he had to say.
But, in fact, I’ve enjoyed the book—even found it gripping. The author was a brilliant man, and a fine wordsmith—with a clever sense of humor. I sometimes disagreed with his declarations, yet reading these essays made me ponder just why I believe what I believe. And I was inspired to try to look at things from his point of view. I realize it’s a good thing to contemplate how “the other side” sees things, and to do so with curiosity rather than belligerence.
Maybe even more than mere curiosity: empathy. This fellow raised serious issues that shouldn’t be brushed aside in haste because I subscribe to the general principles of the opposing political party. Perhaps what is true—if there exist any absolutes that can be determined—is somewhere in the middle. (I think he’d argue against that point.)
Since I moved to my new hometown—a little over a year ago—it’s been my modus operandi to shut up and listen. This was initially an act of self-preservation. I became tight-lipped about my political leanings to protect myself until I knew who was safe, and with whom I should be guarded. But shutting my opinionated mouth had an unexpected reward: It expanded my friendship circle tenfold.
In the book, I read that conservatives think liberals are stupid and liberals think conservatives are mean. That was funny. And holds more than a nugget of truth. But I’m now part of a big “family” that I suspect is mostly conservative, and I don’t think any of them would suddenly view me as stupid if they learned how I vote. Nor do I find any of them mean. On the contrary—these folks would come to my aid in a New York minute.
While I experienced the November 3 blue wave like a professional surfer, I could see that some of my friends had a sensation closer to drowning. They were scared. Maybe angry. Definitely depressed. Much the same as I felt when Trump got elected two years ago and I found myself having what would logically be called a panic attack. It was an awful sensation. It felt life-threatening.
This is when we need empathy to really kick in. There should be no gloating in a democracy.
Alas, the final chapters of this book of essays were a letdown. I could not refute the author’s insistence that given wars were “the right thing” or that administrations that didn’t go to war were wrong. I don’t know enough about the politics of these historical events to argue. But the tone of the book had changed. To anger. Or at least superiority without humor—akin to scolding. The author lost my attention. I think there’s a lesson in there.
I hope our newly elected leaders will emphasize that they’re in office to serve all their constituents—not just their political supporters. And that everyday Americans going about their business will do at least as much listening as pontificating. Until we can all do that, compromise will be elusive. And compromise is a good thing. We can’t all be right.