The Historic District Commission sometimes receives an application for work already completed. In many cases, the commission issues a belated approval, along with a reminder that exterior projects in the historic district require an application.
At the Nov. 4 HDC meeting, an application by James Smith and Stacey Humphreys led to a minor confrontation. The application dealt with changes at 180 N. Main St., a contributing property dating to 1900. The owners had installed a covered soda machine and seating area, and Commissioner Peter Graham pointed out that this addition would benefit anyone walking between the downtown area and the parking facilities at the train depot. The other commissioners all agreed, but several took issue with a metal shed that had been placed on the property.
Smith explained that he installed the shed to protect several motorcycles. He said this would be a temporary structure, which he would replace with a permanent building. Graham complimented the owners on the work they had already performed on the property, but objected strongly to the shed. He said other cities would demand immediate removal of a building placed without a permit.
“We want to work with our residents, but we need to enforce commission guidelines,” he said.
Commissioner Dee Bright told the owners, “You should have come to us first.” Bright pointed out that the HDC had recently required a property owner to remove a non-compliant carport, and another carport had its metal siding replaced with wood.
Smith became combative as he complained about the process. Commissioners listened to his protests but rejected the application for the shed. Only one commissioner voted in favor, with three opposed and two abstentions.
At 179 N. Main St., the non-contributing property dates to 1960. Skye Shideler’s application included a simulation of the appearance of decorative iron scroll work to be added at the front peak of the building. The property, formerly the location of Cafe Santa Fe, will become a wine bar in the coming year. All approved the application.
The commission had received a request for opinion at 75 Hillside Ave. A prospective buyer asked about adding an attached pergola. Cassie Dishman, director of Planning and Community Development, said the property is not currently under contract, so the commission did not have a formal application to consider. The building dates to 1895 and is considered contributing.
The property’s location complicated the decision. Although the pergola would be located on the rear of the building, that side faces N. Main Street. Dishman said she had solicited an opinion from the Arkansas Historic Preservation Program, and that agency expressed concerns over attaching a pergola to the historic building. The AHPP did not object to placing a pergola as a standalone structure.
Commissioner Frank Green admired the “lovely addition,” but had reservations about whether it met guidelines. Dishman said she would relay the opinions to the potential buyers.
In other business:
- Dishman recapped a recent visit to a training session in Hot Springs. She said the state offers the session every couple of years, and she attended with commissioners Katie Lopez and Cory O’Hara. Dishman described a session on heritage tourism, which fits well with the situation in Eureka Springs. Dishman shared research showing that heritage tourists spend more money and stay longer in a location, supporting museums, restaurants, and lodging. Lopez mentioned a session on community engagement, especially involving younger people, to get them involved with preservation. She also spoke highly of a session on window restoration. O’Hara said he learned a lot about the National Registry, as well as methods to increase communication between the HDC and the public.
- Dishman asked commissioners to think about a workshop in early 2027 to consider the effects of artificial intelligence and some other issues not currently covered by guidelines.
- A work session is scheduled for Nov. 19-21 to continue restoration of the floor in the basement of The Aud. Volunteers are needed from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m., and those volunteers are most needed on the first day.
- Bright said tickets for the Christmas Tour of Homes would go on sale on Nov. 6 and will probably sell out.
- The HDC will next meet at 6 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Level III applications were due Nov. 5, and Level II applications were due Nov. 11.
