American Insights

102

American Insights: The Old, Familiar, and Ugly

On the evening of October 25, 2026, the sitting president of the United States stood before a crowd at McMorran Place arena in Port Huron, Michigan, and said that if Abdul El-Sayed won the Senate race, El-Sayed “would be the only senator that will have to go through a metal detector before he’s allowed to go into the Senate.”

He called a sitting candidate for the United States Senate—an American citizen and educated physician and epidemiologist—a “jihadist,” a “Muslim Brotherhood member,” and claimed he wanted to impose Sharia law on the country. For good measure, he mocked El-Sayed’s name, focusing on his middle name, Mohammed, to spotlight his Muslim heritage.

There is no evidence for any of the president’s ridiculous comments. But the lie is almost beside the larger point. What Trump deployed in Port Huron was not merely a campaign tactic. It was something much older and much uglier.

This country has spoken this language of exclusion and fear before. On the eve of the Civil War, pro-slavery statesmen like Robert Toombs of Georgia argued that Black freedom would put “in eminent peril the liberties of the white race”—that equality between the races was “denied by an irreversible law of nature.”

During Reconstruction, Democrats in 1868 declared the new South Carolina constitution “the work of Northern adventurers, Southern renegades, and ignorant negroes,” establishing, they raged, “negro supremacy on the ruins of the proud Caucasian race, whose sovereignty on earth God has ordained.”

Women were barred from the ballot because they were “emotional creatures, incapable of making a sound political decision.”

Senator James Blaine of Maine argued in 1879 that the choice facing the American West was simply “the civilization of Christ or the civilization of Confucius”—that Chinese Americans could never be compatible with the white population and would “inevitably degrade us.”

In the early 1950s, Senator Joseph McCarthy stood before the Senate and declared he held a list of more than 200 communists “made known to the Secretary of State”—names that proved, he insisted, that the government had been hollowed out from within; the list never held up, but the fear it unleashed did not need to. Harry Truman’s Secretary of State, Dean Acheson, was dubbed “Red Dean” by McCarthy.

And when the civil rights movement demanded what the Constitution had promised for a century, Governor George Wallace of Alabama warned in 1963 that those pushing integration wanted to turn the country into “a mongrel unit of one”—that their real aim was “the international racism of the liberals” in league with communist philosophy.

The list goes on.

After the terror attacks on September 11, 2001, Muslim Americans faced a version of this same thing—suspicion of an entire community based on the acts of a few, their loyalty to the country questioned by default. At the time, Congressman Saxby Chambliss of Georgia reacted by telling law enforcement to “arrest every Muslim that crosses the state line.” Six days after the attacks, Louisiana congressman John Cooksey mocked Muslims and the hijab, saying that those with “a diaper on his head” should be pulled over.

When, in 2008, America elected Barack Obama its first Black president, a movement rose to prove he wasn’t really American at all—the birth certificate was forged, the name was foreign, the allegiances were African (or, strangely, Islamic) rather than American.

In 2026, the vocabulary has been updated, but the structure and spirit is identical. When the sitting president calls El-Sayed a jihadist, he is not making a factual claim. He is doing what the South Carolina Democrats of 1868 did when they called Benjamin Franklin Randolph an “ignorant negro.” He is declaring that this person does not belong here—that his presence among the country’s governing class is by definition a threat, that the proper response to his candidacy is not a counterargument but slander, racism, and a metal detector.

The word “jihadist” does the same work in 2026 that “negro supremacy” did in 1868, or “communist” in the 1950s. They are accusations without evidence, designed not to inform but to alarm. It tells a story that something alien and dangerous has gotten too close to power and that the natural order of things is under assault.

What is remarkable is how consistent the panic is. In 1868, the mere presence of a Black man making laws for South Carolina—as in the other former Confederate states—was described as the ruin of civilization. In 2026, the mere candidacy of a Muslim-American physician for the United States Senate requires, in the president’s telling, extraordinary security measures.  

The republic, apparently, can survive a great deal—wars, depressions, pandemics, insurrections—but not this man walking through that door without being searched first. Why? Because his skin color is darker, his faith different, his name unique to the tongue.

In the perennial tug-of-war between America’s better and worse selves, it is not difficult to see which side of the soul all of this reflects.

But in June 1957, President Dwight Eisenhower showed us what the other side of the American soul looks like. He attended the dedication of the Islamic Center of Washington—the first mosque in the nation’s capital. He said: “I should like to assure you, my Islamic friends, that under the American Constitution, under American tradition, and in American hearts, this Center, this place of worship, is just as welcome as could be any similar facility of any other religion.”

A five-star general and sitting president, in the middle of the Cold War, standing inside a mosque in Washington. That is the American tradition that Trump is betraying.

El-Sayed doesn’t need defending as a politician. He needs defending as an American. What Eisenhower understood, Trump has forgotten—if, in fact, he ever really knew it at all: that America is at its strongest and best when it means what it says about who belongs here. Our founding makes it clear: “That all men are created equal.”

Ultimately, the slander didn’t work. El-Sayed was elected the first Muslim-American senator in United States history. And in November, he walked into the Capitol the same way every senator-elect does—through the front door. 

Leave a Comment